In a landmark decision, a Chicago jury has awarded $24,141,000 to the family of two children who suffered severe lead poisoning while living in a Chicago Housing Authority (CHA) apartment in Rogers Park.
The verdict was delivered on January 15, 2025, after a six-week trial that revealed decades of negligence by the CHA.
The Case and Its Background
The lawsuit stemmed from conditions in a CHA Scattered Site unit at 7715 North Marshfield Avenue. The apartment, plagued by a leaking roof, deteriorating paint, and unaddressed lead hazards, had a documented history of poisoning multiple children over the years.
Despite federal and city investigations highlighting the lead risks in the 1990s and 2000s, the CHA failed to act or disclose the dangers to tenants.
In 2014, Shanna Jordan moved into the apartment with her newborn son, Jah’mir Collins, and her older daughter, Morgan Collins.
Later, Jordan’s granddaughter, Amiah McGee-Collins, joined the household. Initially healthy, the children began showing developmental issues as they grew.
By the time Jah’mir was diagnosed with lead poisoning in 2019, Amiah’s blood lead level had reached nearly 10 times the CDC’s reference limit.
Evidence presented at trial showed the CHA knew about the risks but did not inform the family or take corrective action.
The Jury’s Decision
The jury allocated $20.6 million to Amiah, now six years old, and $3.5 million to her 10-year-old brother, Jah’mir.
Attorneys for the family argued that the children’s cognitive and emotional development had been irreparably harmed, with effects likely to persist throughout their lives.
“This case cried out for justice,” said Matthew Sims, an attorney representing the family. “What happened to these children was completely avoidable if the CHA had followed federal regulations designed to protect tenants from lead exposure.”
The CHA’s Negligence
Evidence presented during the trial painted a grim picture of systemic negligence within the CHA. Internal communications revealed that lead risks were reconfirmed in 2017, yet the agency withheld the information from tenants.
Attempts to shift blame to private property managers and the children’s mothers—who had lodged over 50 complaints about unsafe conditions—further underscored the CHA’s failure to fulfill its responsibilities.
Dr. David Jacobs, a former HUD official, testified during the trial, describing the CHA’s actions as “gross negligence.” The jury’s verdict has brought renewed attention to the need for transparency and accountability in public housing management.
Health Impacts of Lead Poisoning
According to health experts, lead poisoning can result in irreversible damage, including cognitive deficits, behavioral problems, and long-term physical health issues.
Amiah, who once could write her name and count to 30, began regressing by age three, struggling with basic tasks and emotional regulation. X-rays showed lead in her bones, which will continue to release toxins into her system over time.
Reactions to the Verdict
Sims called the verdict a step toward justice but emphasized the broader implications. “This is a moment for the CHA to reflect and commit to meaningful reform,” he said.
Fellow attorney Melanie VanOverloop expressed hope that the case would spark systemic changes within the CHA, ensuring no more children suffer similar harm.
The CHA released a statement expressing sympathy for the family but voiced disappointment in the verdict, stating that they are “reviewing options.” Requests for clarification on steps taken to address lead hazards in the building went unanswered.
A Call for Reform
This case serves as a stark reminder of the ongoing risks posed by lead in older housing and the critical importance of regulatory compliance.
Advocates hope the $24.1 million verdict will compel housing authorities nationwide to prioritize tenant safety and eliminate lead hazards from public housing.
The family’s attorneys and health experts agree: no child should have to endure the lifelong consequences of lead poisoning, and agencies tasked with providing safe housing must be held accountable.
Leave a Comment